On any given day I read the blogs of a rabid baseball fan, a lesbian, a woman who has had 8 miscarriages, and a former web designer who is now a stay at home mom. Does that mean I secretly want to be a baseball fan, a lesbian (I'm straight) or a mother, especially given that I'm in my mid 40's and sterilized? Very doubtful.
My criteria for reading blogsare funny and interesting. I agree with your assessment of the Gagowski blog...how many times can you read "Jerimaiah is my spayshul boy...He peed on me today and it was truly water from Jaysus" ? And yes, I sometimes read trainwreck blogs. It's a guilty pleasure.
I don't know why someone would want to correspond with a Moo about Moo stuff, and I have no patience for trolling and harassing Moos or WannaBes. But I don't think what the OP did was wrong. It sounds like a Moo Wanna Be was trying to start some shit and make false allegations about this page. If he/she tried to diffuse the situation, more power to him/her. This page serves a purpose and I don't want it bombarded by trolls.