from junkfood science
Posted by mercurior
|
from junkfood science May 23, 2008 | Registered: 19 years ago Posts: 4,402 |
http://junkfoodscience.blogspot.com/2008/05/vision-for-healthy-state.html
Do you ever wonder what kind of policy advice the leaders in your state get? The Wisconsin Policy Research Institute, which says it’s a free market think tank that advises government leaders on key policy issues and conducts regular opinion polls, produces a daily newsfeed that managers in Wisconsin read each morning.
Today, state administrators received in their inboxes recommendations for a “healthy Wisconsin.”
It’s a vision for the state-run healthcare program, providing universal healthcare coverage for all, modeled after the Wisconsin Works* welfare reform. It was written by political scientist, David Dodenhoff, Ph.D.:
What Healthy Wisconsin Should Cost (And Almost Certainly Won't)
...‘What, exactly, do you bring to the table?’ I have the same question when it comes to Healthy Wisconsin. The state intends to provide universal health care coverage—secure, affordable, high-quality coverage. It sounds like the health care equivalent of the dream girl. Naturally, it’s got me wondering: what, exactly, are Wisconsinites bringing to the table?
Fear not; I have an idea...There was a fundamental idea of reciprocity here: we’ll help you, but only if you’re willing to help yourself... Consider this scenario. You’re at an appointment with your Healthy Wisconsin doctor. She gives you a routine physical and finds that your weight is a potential health issue. So, she sets a body mass index (BMI) value that she’d like you to achieve within six months. She also gives you an exercise and nutrition regimen to help you reach your goal. But here’s the catch: if you don’t get within 10 percent of your doctor-recommended BMI in the allotted time, your coverage under Healthy Wisconsin is suspended. You can apply for reinstatement, but only once you’ve achieved your target BMI value. Until then, you’re on your own.
Again, you see the logic of reciprocity: we’ll help you, but only if you’re willing to help yourself.
He is proposing that the state prescribe compulsory preventive health regimens on what you eat and on your lifestyle, regardless of their efficacy, through state doctors. Ideally, healthcare would be denied until you comply.
You can already see it coming: As taxes go higher and higher to fund healthcare for everyone, resentment and blame will build among taxpayers and will be directed at those perceived to be bringing on their health problems themselves or to be costing the rest of citizens. Only fit, young and healthy people will be socially desirable.
He goes on to refute the two most popular objections to his proposals, arguing:
Here’s the first one: “You can’t have government dictating people’s behavior like that! It’s a violation of their rights!” But what rights are being violated here? Neither the state nor the federal constitutions include a right to hassle-free health care. (I checked. I even checked the emanations and penumbras.) Free health care is an act of beneficence by the state, and by the taxpayers who fund the state. It’s a gift horse. Accordingly, there shouldn’t be any complaining about its teeth. If you want the health care, you’re going to have to deal with the hassle. If you don’t want the hassle, don’t take the health care.
Here’s the second objection: “You can’t have government dictating people’s behavior like that! That’s Big Brother! I thought you people were all about small government, not government messing with the niggling details of people’s lives.”
“We people” are, in fact, all about small government. Healthy Wisconsin, on the other hand, is big government. If the state of Wisconsin is committed to practicing big government, then it might as well do so in the most constructive way possible. The most constructive way possible in this case, as in the case of welfare*, is to insist on reciprocity....
He goes on to tell readers who might object, to relax and that it won’t be so bad. To help get them started, his advice is to skip the fried foods...
Political science is not medical science. What do you get from government? Politics.
*********************************************************************************************************************************
I just post the stories, for interest.. for everyone
Lord, what fools these mortals be!
- A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Act III, Scene ii
Voltaire said: "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities."
H.L.Mencken wrote:"The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.â€
Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former. Albert Einstein
Do you ever wonder what kind of policy advice the leaders in your state get? The Wisconsin Policy Research Institute, which says it’s a free market think tank that advises government leaders on key policy issues and conducts regular opinion polls, produces a daily newsfeed that managers in Wisconsin read each morning.
Today, state administrators received in their inboxes recommendations for a “healthy Wisconsin.”
It’s a vision for the state-run healthcare program, providing universal healthcare coverage for all, modeled after the Wisconsin Works* welfare reform. It was written by political scientist, David Dodenhoff, Ph.D.:
What Healthy Wisconsin Should Cost (And Almost Certainly Won't)
...‘What, exactly, do you bring to the table?’ I have the same question when it comes to Healthy Wisconsin. The state intends to provide universal health care coverage—secure, affordable, high-quality coverage. It sounds like the health care equivalent of the dream girl. Naturally, it’s got me wondering: what, exactly, are Wisconsinites bringing to the table?
Fear not; I have an idea...There was a fundamental idea of reciprocity here: we’ll help you, but only if you’re willing to help yourself... Consider this scenario. You’re at an appointment with your Healthy Wisconsin doctor. She gives you a routine physical and finds that your weight is a potential health issue. So, she sets a body mass index (BMI) value that she’d like you to achieve within six months. She also gives you an exercise and nutrition regimen to help you reach your goal. But here’s the catch: if you don’t get within 10 percent of your doctor-recommended BMI in the allotted time, your coverage under Healthy Wisconsin is suspended. You can apply for reinstatement, but only once you’ve achieved your target BMI value. Until then, you’re on your own.
Again, you see the logic of reciprocity: we’ll help you, but only if you’re willing to help yourself.
He is proposing that the state prescribe compulsory preventive health regimens on what you eat and on your lifestyle, regardless of their efficacy, through state doctors. Ideally, healthcare would be denied until you comply.
You can already see it coming: As taxes go higher and higher to fund healthcare for everyone, resentment and blame will build among taxpayers and will be directed at those perceived to be bringing on their health problems themselves or to be costing the rest of citizens. Only fit, young and healthy people will be socially desirable.
He goes on to refute the two most popular objections to his proposals, arguing:
Here’s the first one: “You can’t have government dictating people’s behavior like that! It’s a violation of their rights!” But what rights are being violated here? Neither the state nor the federal constitutions include a right to hassle-free health care. (I checked. I even checked the emanations and penumbras.) Free health care is an act of beneficence by the state, and by the taxpayers who fund the state. It’s a gift horse. Accordingly, there shouldn’t be any complaining about its teeth. If you want the health care, you’re going to have to deal with the hassle. If you don’t want the hassle, don’t take the health care.
Here’s the second objection: “You can’t have government dictating people’s behavior like that! That’s Big Brother! I thought you people were all about small government, not government messing with the niggling details of people’s lives.”
“We people” are, in fact, all about small government. Healthy Wisconsin, on the other hand, is big government. If the state of Wisconsin is committed to practicing big government, then it might as well do so in the most constructive way possible. The most constructive way possible in this case, as in the case of welfare*, is to insist on reciprocity....
He goes on to tell readers who might object, to relax and that it won’t be so bad. To help get them started, his advice is to skip the fried foods...
Political science is not medical science. What do you get from government? Politics.
*********************************************************************************************************************************
I just post the stories, for interest.. for everyone
Lord, what fools these mortals be!
- A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Act III, Scene ii
Voltaire said: "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities."
H.L.Mencken wrote:"The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.â€
Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former. Albert Einstein
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.