To women like that, the gift doesn't count unless it's delivered/done on the calendar holiday. The older women in my family were like that. They'd tell their sons they wanted yard work done for them as MD presents. Since some of those men had wives and kids, they'd say "I want to spend MD with Wife and our kids. How about I come over and do the yard on Saturday?" With a long-suffering *sigh* the old bat would reply "oh well, never mind then. If you can't do the yard for me as a
real present (ie -
on MD, not before or after), then don't bother." What followed was the dude trying to compromise, telling his wife that it would only take a few hours to do Mom's yard, he'd be home in plenty of time to grill. In reality, Mom would micro-manage the yard chores to an extent that her son was there most of the day, making for a very pissed spouse.