I'd like to know where one can find a low stress job where you work 12-15 hours a week and make $75k per year with benefits because I would retire immediately and start doing that.
If only choosing between jobs were that cut and dried. About four years ago I was making $90k, working 40 hours a week and I was bored silly. My company re-organized and one entire department had nothing to do. After a couple years of that I got really bored and frustrated. Being bored, under-utilized and put out to pasture was harder to take than I thought and I had to leave because it was getting to me. Enter my current job with a 30% raise and more hours, but it was in a topic that interested me, great mission and a known boss. I also knew it would be my last job with the company and I wanted to up my pension calculation, which is based on one's high three salary.
About a year after I took the job, the known boss exited, to be replaced by a new, extremely ineffective/absent boss. Two major reorganizations later and I'm at the opposite end of the spectrum with more damn work than i'll ever be able to accomplish and personnel challenges/deadwood. Upper management has no idea what I'm doing....my boss wanders in every now and then and tells me "great job!" but won't allow me to fill vacancies. I'm at the end of my career and positioning myself for post employment. With the liberal use of sick leave I can survive another year.
Back to topic, the only thing I would question is how stable the $75k a year job is? Could the job go away? Is personal fulfillment important to you? How many more years do you have to work?
I just wrote, "I've sometimes taken a job with more stress because the topic or experience interested me and I could leverage it to a better job."
But yanno, that isn't true. I have only left jobs when I felt they were intolerable and there was a reason to leave.
Option 1 would be fine with me.