My DH and I saw a story about this study last night on the news, and we both thought this study is pure B.S. I don't understand why people commonly link "responsible and ready to settle down in marriage" with "wanting to breed."
My DH and I will celebrate our ninth wedding anniversary next week, and I always tend to get a little mushy this time of year and think back to the weeks and days leading up to our wedding.
I remember when we went to our priest for premarital counseling, which was required by our church. Our minister - a happily married CF man in his 40s - asked DH why he wanted to marry me, and DH said that he could see himself creating a home with me. At that time, DH was living in his parents' rental home and making updates on it in exchange for rent, and he specifically said that while he was doing the wallpapering and the painting for his parents' rental house, he wished he was doing it for a home that he would share with me. He also saw us traveling together and sharing some of the same dreams.
And I mentioned the happy marriage that my parents had - they've now been married 50 years - and said that I wanted DH and me to continue to grow old together. When we got engaged, we already known each other for more than 10 years, and we had both grown up from being college freshmen to being in our late 20s. (I had just turned 30 when we married, and DH was almost 30).
I remember that neither one of us mentioned "having children" as a reason for wanting to get married. Our minister did ask us about children, and we both said that we wanted to wait a few years before having them. It was only after we had been married five years that we realized we didn't have to have children at all.
I actually think the desire to have children is a pretty bad reason to get married. A woman who goes into a marriage expecting that her partner is eager to breed may become very bitter and disappointed when she realizes that he is not - and I've seen marriages fall apart because the woman has expectations that her partner doesn't share.
I definitely think couples should discuss whether or not to have children, and when to have children if they decide to have them, BEFORE the wedding. But I also think a woman who picks out a man for marriage just because she wants to breed is a pretty stupid woman. And it's just plain dumb for a woman to assume that a man is a breeder just because of the way he looks.
There is no guarantee that any person can have children - medical problems and infertility do happen - so if having children is the only goal of marriage, what happens to the marriage if one of the partners can't breed? Or what happens if the couple has a child and the child dies? If children were the only reason for the marriage, then the marriage is not going to last if the couple isn't raising children for some reason.
My parents have friends who divorced after their children were grown because there was nothing left to their marriage once the children were no longer dependant on them. These are couples who married and starting having children right away. I am lucky that my parents were married for almost seven years before they had their first child (unusual in the 1950s and early '60s), and for 50 years, there has been more to their marriage than raising my sisters and me.